Tuesday, 1 May 2012

Defensive Discussions 'Player of the Year' Awards


It s that time of the year again where we at Defensive Discussions decide on our Player of the Year awards. Once again a defender was not shortlisted by the PFA for their award but Tottenham Hotspurs Kyle Walker took the PFA ‘Young Player of the Year’ award. The England international was even surprised, “"I was a bit surprised because defenders don't normally get these awards and get the limelight as much as the centre-forwards," he said. This is the second year we at Defensive Discussions want to recognize the men in trenches by handing out our very own awards:

Player of the Year

Vincent Kompany

Fabricio Coloccini

Kyle Walker

A superstar amongst stars
Martin Skrtel

Joelan Lescott


The Manchester City captain has become the rock and leader of that multi million pound squad. It was no surprise that the blip the Manchester club had in March coincided with the injury of their skipper. The man is a presence back along with his partner Joelan Lescott, who has also had a fantastic campaign. You couldn’t ask for anything more from your centre back he is strong, quick, composed on the ball, and has that knack of sniffing out danger. There was no doubt in my mind that the Belgium international was the best defender of the 2011/12 season and may still add a Premier League medal to top off his fantastic year.

Young Player of the Year

Kyle Walker

Danny Simpson

Stephen Caulker


Whip!!!!!!!!!
This was a close race but I had to go with the “PFA Young Player of the Year”. The full backs form may have dipped in the same way as his teams did but it does not take away the season the right back has had this year. Along with his blinding speed and attacking prowess the boy is a good defender which is very rare for the modern day attacking full back. Not only does the opposing left back have to worry about the winger but this Sheffield born full back bombing down his side too. Walker was rewarded by ex England manager, Fabio Capello with an England call up against World and European Champions, Spain. Although he came on as a substitute that day at Wembley, three days later he made his full debut against Sweden. Going to the Ukraine this summer is a realistic goal, especially if his current club manager, Harry Redknapp is appointed as England’s next manager.

Full Back of the Year

Kyle Walker

Leighton Baines

Danny Simpson

Jose Enrique

Micah Richards


Billy Jones

Another fantastic year for the scouse left back!
I have already given my reasons in the “Young Player of the Year” section to why this lad has been the best full back this year but Danny Simpson and Leighton Baines were a close second. Simpson has been a revelation this season helping Newcastle United to a lofty 4th in the league and Champions League football a realistic goal. The performances that stood out to me were the games against his former club, Manchester United. He cleared two off the line at Old Trafford to help his side earn a draw and at St James’s Park he repeated his epic performance with yet another goal line clearance to beat the Champions on his birthday. Leighton Baines is 7 out of 10 every week at least. The man would have 40 caps for England if it wasn’t for Ashley Cole. The local boy helped his side reach the FA Cup semi final which saw them lose to bitter rivals, Liverpool but may help them finish higher in the league. A dead cert to board that plane to Ukraine and I would have qualms if he played over Ashley Cole.


Worst Defender of the Year

Roger Johnson

Club captain....What a joke!
I have seen this man play live on a few occasions and mentioned in a previous article (name of article) that Premier League clubs should look to buy the centre back from relegated Birmingham City. Wolverhampton Wanderers was his destination this season and was quickly named captain by Mick McCarthy. The reason I have chosen Johnson for this award is not only performance based, because saying he has been poor this season is an understatement but his attitude. Wolves had just sacked their manager, fighting for their lives after a 5-0 beating from Fulham, and the fans thought things couldn’t be any worse. They were wrong! Less than 24 hours later, Johnson decided to turn up for training drunk after a night out the previous night. The captain turning up intoxicated doesn’t show commitment to the cause, especially when he was a major reason for their shortcomings. I couldn’t imagine what the fans were thinking reading that the next day still trying to come to terms with their side being humiliated the day before. The problems did not stop there, his form never improved and in another loss, the club captain put his club in the headlines for all the wrong reasons yet again. During another loss the Molineux the Wolverhampton faithful saw Johnson square up to his own teammate, Wayne Hennessey and they were not even losing at this point. It doesn’t stop there, instead of fighting tooth and nail with relegation rivals Bolton, the centre back looked to put no effort into stopping Kevin Davies from entering his box and scoring to score the eventual winner. The man has been a complete let down and after the defeat to Manchester City, Wolves will be playing in the Championship next season. Will Johnson be there? Who knows but who would want to buy a player after this showing this season.

Back Four 2011/12

Right Back- Kyle Walker

Centre Back- Vincent Kompany

Centre Back- Fabricio Coloccini

Left Back- Leighton Baines


No comments:

Post a Comment